Diplomats from more than 100 countries, including the U.S., Russia and China, began a five-day meeting in Geneva on Monday to discuss a possible framework for regulating lethal autonomous weapons systems.
The talks come as hopes for meaningful, binding regulation of AI in warfare appear slim, according to CBC, which reported that insiders say time may be running out.
What the Geneva meeting covers and who attends
The meeting is held under the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons and runs from Monday to Friday. More than 100 countries that are party to the convention will be represented, including Canada, the U.S., Russia and China, CBC reported.
The agenda includes lethal autonomous weapons systems and a possible framework for regulations.
Guterres's warning and end-2026 treaty target
UN Secretary-General António Guterres warned in August that the world was nearing a "moral red line," where autonomous weapons such as AI-powered drones could kill without human involvement, CBC reported.
Guterres has said he wants a legally binding treaty on autonomous weapons by the end of 2026. He has made the call as AI increasingly becomes a factor in deadly strikes, CBC reported.
Some experts say the use of AI to decide where and when to strike is an even more pressing concern than the weapons themselves, according to CBC.
Why the U.S., Russia and China resist binding rules
CBC reported that the world's biggest military powers, including the U.S., Russia and China, have so far blocked any serious attempts at binding rules.
Paul Lushenko, a senior fellow at Cornell University Tech Policy Institute and a retiring U.S. military officer, told CBC that leaders fear losing their competitive advantage. He said that militaries broadly recognize the moral implications of AI, but that the dominant view among the most powerful militaries is that they cannot trust rivals to follow any rules they adopt.
"That's a really challenging position to be in," Lushenko said.
Lushenko said he does not expect any "bona fide international policy" to come out of this week's meetings.
The record of recent negotiations is mixed. In September, U.S. and Russian diplomats cut key safety provisions from a draft treaty on the final day of talks, according to the Washington Post as reported by CBC. The reported provisions would have required predictable and reliable system operation, ethical considerations, and human review of military targets picked by AI before strikes.
In February, about one-third of the countries at a military AI summit in Spain, including Canada, agreed to a declaration on governing the use of AI in warfare. The U.S. and China opted out, CBC reported.
How AI is being used in Ukraine, Gaza and Iran
Ukraine and Russia are both increasingly using AI in battle as their war approaches its fifth year, CBC reported. In August, the New York Times reported that a Russian drone operated entirely by AI killed three Ukrainian civilians, CBC noted.
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy, addressing the UN in September, warned of a "real possibility" that AI will soon begin to decide what happens on the battlefield. "We need peace before we reach that point," he said.
CBC reported that Israeli intelligence officers told +972 Magazine and Local Call that the military's Lavender AI system allegedly identified 37,000 targets in Gaza. One officer said soldiers had about 20 seconds to review each target before a strike. These are allegations, and Israel has been accused of using AI to choose targets.
The Pentagon has declared the U.S. military an "AI-first fighting force," CBC reported. According to CBC, the U.S. used Anthropic's Claude chatbot to help identify nearly 1,000 targets in the first 24 hours of its war with Iran in February.
After a U.S. missile strike on a girls' school in Minab, American senators raised concerns over the use of AI tools, including Palantir's Maven Smart System, in target selection, CBC reported. The concerns have not been resolved in the reporting available, and CBC said they did not deter the military.
The available reporting does not include the outcome of the Geneva meeting. Whether the talks produce any framework or draft text, and whether the U.S., Russia and China would accept binding rules, remains unclear. Lushenko does not expect a binding result.