Archive Videos E-Paper
Breaking News
● Historic Muslim Victories in the 2026 U.S. Midterm Elections: Who Won and How Many? ● Deadly Attacks Hit Riyadh Airport Again as Saudi Arabia Vows Strong Response ● 2026 World Cup Golden Glove: Unai Simón Heavily Favored After Record-Breaking Run ● House passes Sunshine Protection Act to make Daylight Saving Time permanent ● Trump Administration Ends ‘Duration of Status’ for International Students, Introduces Fixed Visa Stay Limits- New immigration rule would require many foreign students to apply for extensions if studies exceed four years ● The Final Showdown: Spain vs. Argentina – A World Cup Finale for the Ages-Will Spain begin a new era of dominance, or will Argentina write one more unforgettable chapter in the legendary story of Lionel Messi? ● New York Becomes First U.S. State to Pause New Large Data Center Construction ● U.S. Senator Lindsey Graham Dies at 71 Following Sudden Illness ● Historic Muslim Victories in the 2026 U.S. Midterm Elections: Who Won and How Many? ● Deadly Attacks Hit Riyadh Airport Again as Saudi Arabia Vows Strong Response ● 2026 World Cup Golden Glove: Unai Simón Heavily Favored After Record-Breaking Run ● House passes Sunshine Protection Act to make Daylight Saving Time permanent ● Trump Administration Ends ‘Duration of Status’ for International Students, Introduces Fixed Visa Stay Limits- New immigration rule would require many foreign students to apply for extensions if studies exceed four years ● The Final Showdown: Spain vs. Argentina – A World Cup Finale for the Ages-Will Spain begin a new era of dominance, or will Argentina write one more unforgettable chapter in the legendary story of Lionel Messi? ● New York Becomes First U.S. State to Pause New Large Data Center Construction ● U.S. Senator Lindsey Graham Dies at 71 Following Sudden Illness
USA

Supreme Court Declines Implicit Bias Training Case for California Doctors

W
World Desk View profile →

16 Nov 2026, 09:31 PM

13 • 4 min read fb x
Exterior of the US Supreme Court building in Washington, with a physician's stethoscope resting on a stack of legal papers

The Supreme Court on Monday, Nov. 16, declined to hear a challenge to California's rule requiring implicit bias training for doctors, leaving in place a lower-court ruling that rejected a First Amendment claim against the mandate. Three justices said they would have taken the case.

The denial matters because the ruling it leaves standing treats California's mandatory courses as government speech, which falls outside First Amendment review. Justice Clarence Thomas used his dissent to argue that the Court should revisit that reasoning.

California adopted the requirement in 2019. The legislature said unconscious prejudices often contribute to unequal health care based on a patient's race, gender, age, disability or other characteristic. It cited African Americans being prescribed less pain medication than White patients with similar problems, and women being less likely to survive a heart attack when treated by a male doctor, according to USA Today.

What the Court did and did not decide

The order was a denial of review. It did not rule on the merits of the First Amendment claim. Four justices must agree to hear an appeal, and that did not happen, according to USA Today.

The sources differ on how the three dissenters lined up. USA Today names Thomas, Samuel Alito and Neil Gorsuch as the three who wanted to take the case. Pacific Legal Foundation says Thomas, joined by Alito, dissented from the denial and that Gorsuch would have granted the petition. Courthouse News Service gives the same account.

Clarence Thomas dissent on government speech

Thomas argued that the training requirement is not government speech but a rule that forces private instructors to communicate certain messages. He wrote that the government-speech doctrine should not be used as a cover for censorship or a cloak for compelled speech, according to USA Today.

Thomas also wrote that the state cannot escape First Amendment review by regulating a field heavily. "A State cannot regulate its way out of First Amendment scrutiny," he wrote, as quoted by Pacific Legal Foundation.

Courthouse News Service reported that Thomas warned the Ninth Circuit's logic could let California require continuing medical education instructors to deliver the state's preferred message on the availability of abortion or the ethics of gender-affirming surgery. He said that result does not follow from the Court's precedents or the Constitution.

The government-speech doctrine holds that the First Amendment restricts government regulation of private speech but does not restrict speech the government itself makes. The dispute is over whether a state rule that requires private teachers to present a message counts as the state's own speech.

Who is Azadeh Khatibi and what is her challenge?

Dr. Azadeh Khatibi is an ophthalmologist who organizes and teaches continuing medical education courses on topics such as retinal tumors and glaucoma. She says implicit bias is not relevant to those subjects and that the mandate takes limited class time away from topics that are, according to Pacific Legal Foundation.

Khatibi and the medical advocacy group Do No Harm argue that the state violated their First Amendment rights by forcing private instructors to deliver its preferred message. Her family fled Tehran when she was six to escape repression, according to her lawyer, as USA Today reported.

Pacific Legal Foundation represents Khatibi and Do No Harm free of charge. The case is Azadeh Khatibi, et al. v. Yip, et al. The foundation says it has active cases in 34 states plus Washington, D.C.

Lower courts dismissed the challenge. The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that the classes are government speech, reasoning that California has long controlled the practice of medicine and that implicit bias is part of the state's "evolving judgment" of essential knowledge for competent doctors, USA Today reported.

Caleb Trotter, a senior attorney with Pacific Legal Foundation, said the training "tells doctors that their colleagues harbor hidden racial prejudices." He added in a statement: "That's not medicine. It's compelled speech." After the order, he said, "While it's disappointing for our clients, we're encouraged that there is support on the Court to review this issue."

Whether California's requirement still applies to doctors

The research does not say whether the rule remains in force for doctors' license renewals, or how California will respond to the order. The denial leaves the Ninth Circuit ruling in place as the governing decision for this case.

The Court has not said whether it will take a similar case later. Thomas's dissent suggests the government-speech question could return, but the research contains no indication of when or whether that will happen.



You're subscribed!

Latest breaking news will be delivered to your inbox.

Stay Informed

Get breaking news and top stories delivered directly to your inbox. No spam, ever.

Unsubscribe anytime. We respect your privacy.