Israeli President Isaac Herzog has tasked Gadi Eisenkot with forming the next government, passing over Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, according to Al Jazeera. Herzog told Eisenkot of the decision on Saturday evening, the president's spokesperson said.
A Gadi Eisenkot government now depends on whether he can build a majority from a Knesset in which neither bloc won one in the October 27 general election. Eisenkot must secure at least 61 of the 120 seats, and the path to that number is narrow.
Herzog's choice and Netanyahu's response
Herzog held consultations with political parties this week before deciding, Al Jazeera reported. Some 67 lawmakers, including from Arab-led parties, endorsed Eisenkot, leader of the Yashar party, while only 46 backed Netanyahu, the current prime minister. Moneycontrol reported that Eisenkot received the mandate after securing recommendations from a majority of the lawmakers the president consulted.
Al Jazeera's Nour Odeh, reporting from Ramallah in the occupied West Bank, said the president "took the predictable route" because Eisenkot had the highest number of recommendations.
Netanyahu had warned before the decision that a government backed by Arab-led parties would be damaging. In a prerecorded video speech, he said: "Such a government, dependent on Islamists, will dismantle the state of Israel from within, as is happening in European countries, and far worse than that," Al Jazeera reported.
Moneycontrol reported that Netanyahu called for a national unity government and warned against "hastily swearing in a government with terrorist supporters."
Herzog was to hand Eisenkot the formal mandate at a ceremony on Sunday, according to Al Jazeera. The research available for this story does not confirm that the ceremony took place.
Israel coalition 61 seats: the arithmetic facing Eisenkot
In the October election, Eisenkot's four-party alliance won 48 seats and Netanyahu's right-wing and religious bloc won 53, Al Jazeera reported. Arab-led parties won a record 19 seats. Netanyahu's Likud won 27 seats, six more than Eisenkot's Yashar party, according to Swarajya.
Eisenkot has ruled out forming a government with the Arab-led parties. Including them would give him a 67-seat bloc, Al Jazeera reported. Winning over the two ultra-Orthodox parties, United Torah Judaism and Shas, would give him exactly 61 seats.
Eisenkot could also form a government with fewer than 61 seats if he wins a parliamentary confidence vote, Al Jazeera reported.
Arab-led parties have a different view of the outcome. Ahmad Tibi, a senior member of the Joint List, which holds 11 seats, told Al Jazeera that Herzog's decision was "expected." He said he expects Eisenkot to lead a minority government "with external support from the Arab parties," adding that this would not be a "dream government" for Arab-led parties.
Tibi said the Joint List was concerned the president would choose a national unity government, a power-sharing deal between Eisenkot and Netanyahu. Odeh noted that although Eisenkot has said he does not want to govern with Arab-led parties, "they both share quite compelling reasons to get rid of Netanyahu."
Eisenkot's conditions and his bloc's divisions
Moneycontrol reported that Eisenkot has indicated he is open to working with Arab parties, subject to conditions including support for designating Hamas a terrorist organisation and dismantling it. Al Jazeera reported that he has ruled out a government with them. The two accounts differ, and the research does not resolve the conflict.
Moneycontrol also reported that some members of Eisenkot's bloc have reservations about a government that depends on Arab-led parties. Differences with Netanyahu over the role of religious parties, military draft exemptions for ultra-Orthodox men and accountability for the security failures around the October 7, 2023 attacks could also complicate a unity deal, Moneycontrol reported.
Eisenkot posted on X that "this is the time to establish a national emergency government. I will do anything possible to prove us worthy." Moneycontrol and Swarajya both reported the post. Eisenkot's Yashar party urged Likud lawmakers to reconsider their alliance with far-right parties, Moneycontrol reported.
Eisenkot led Israel's military from 2015 to 2019. Al Jazeera reported that he sat as an observer in Netanyahu's war cabinet for the first eight months of the Gaza war, which began in October 2023. Swarajya reported that he briefly joined the war cabinet and left the following year, accusing Netanyahu of failing to make progress on ending the war and securing the release of hostages.
What happens if Eisenkot cannot form a government
If Eisenkot fails within the allotted time, Herzog will nominate another candidate, Al Jazeera reported. If that nominee also fails, a parliamentary majority can back a third candidate, who would get a final 14 days.
If no government is formed, a new election will be called within 90 days, and Netanyahu would stay on as caretaker prime minister, Al Jazeera reported.
The open question is whether Eisenkot can reach 61 seats without Arab-led parties, through Shas and United Torah Judaism or a national unity deal, and whether his own bloc will accept a government that depends on Arab-led support.